• Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
grubsheet

grubsheet

# CONSTITUTIONAL CRISIS ERUPTS FIJI

Posted on November 12, 2021 1 Comment

Sharvada Sharma

BREAKING NEWS: Confirmation that the outgoing President, Jioji Konrote, sacked the Solicitor General, Sharvada Sharma, on Wednesday in contravention of the 2013 Constitution stipulation that any dismissal be on the basis of a recommendation from the Judicial Services Commission after a tribunal hearing into any allegation of “misbehaviour”.

It appears that the President ignored the unambiguous Constitutional provisions (see previous posting) that apply to such dismissals on the advice of the Chief Justice, Kamal Kumar, who chairs the Judicial Services Commission. On what basis that advice was made isn’t clear. But it has stunned the legal profession and sent shock waves through the highest levels in Fiji.

Friends say a “deeply shocked” Sharvada Sharma intends to fight for his job and his constitutional right to put his case to a tribunal of three judges by seeking a judicial review of the decision in the High Court. An announcement is pending but one of the lawyers representing him is said to be Richard Naidu of Munro Leys, the well known opposition figure and prospective politician.

The outgoing president

Sharma’s dismissal evidently came after he received a letter last Thursday with a list of 31 questions that he was required to answer by Saturday. Sharma is said to have asked for more time and didn’t receive a response until he received his termination letter. But he specifically denied the allegation of misbehaviour made against him by the Supervisor of Elections, Mohammed Saneem.

It is not known whether Sharma’s failure to meet the Saturday deadline led directly to his dismissal. But it does nothing to alter his undeniable right under the Constitution to have the complaint against him heard by a tribunal, for that tribunal’s findings to be sent to the President and for those findings to be made public.

An astonishing development that goes to the heart of the credibility of the rule of law in Fiji. Three months after the Chief Justice was sworn in to his permanent appointment, the country is now in the throes of a full blown constitutional crisis. If the way the termination of the SG is anything to go by, no-one in high office – including judges and magistrates – has security of tenure and can be dismissed with the barest of nods to judicial procedure.

Chief Justice Kamal Kumar

While the CJ chairs the Judicial Services Commission, he would also normally preside over the process of any judicial review in the High Court. Legal commentators say that given the circumstances, Justice Kumar would be expected to recuse himself and for the matter to be heard by another judge. But there is no requirement for this in law.

One of the biggest stories in Fiji in recent years that has a long way to run and will have far-reaching consequences for confidence in the judiciary and the rule of law.

Reader Interactions

Comments

  1. Ajax says

    November 12, 2021 at 6:35 pm

    SOE’s slide down the slippery slope continues. He will soon encounter splinters on his downwards slide.

    Reply

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published.

Primary Sidebar

  • Email
  • Facebook
  • LinkedIn

Get Posts via Email

Enter your email address to subscribe to Grubsheet and receive notifications of new posts by email.

About Grubsheet

Graham Davis
Grubsheet Feejee is the blogsite of Graham Davis, an award-winning journalist turned communications consultant who was the Fijian Government’s principal communications advisor for six years from 2012 to 2018 and continued to work on Fiji’s global climate and oceans campaign up until the end of the decade.

 

Fiji-born to missionary parents and a dual Fijian-Australian national, Graham spent four decades in the international media before returning to Fiji to work full time in 2012. He reported from many parts of the world for the BBC, ABC, SBS, the Nine and Seven Networks and Sky News and wrote for a range of newspapers and magazines in Australia, New Zealand and Fiji.

 

Graham launched Grubsheet Feejee in 2011 and suspended writing for it after the Fijian election of 2014, by which time he was working at the heart of government. But the website continued to attract hits as a background resource on events in Fiji in the transition back to parliamentary democracy.

 

Grubsheet relaunches in 2020 at one of the most critical times in Fijian history, with the nation reeling from the Covid-19 crisis and Frank Bainimarama’s government shouldering the twin burdens of incumbency and economic disintegration.

 

Grubsheet’s sole agenda is the national interest; the strengthening of Fiji’s ties with the democracies; upholding equal rights for all citizens; government that is genuinely transparent and free of corruption and nepotism; and upholding Fiji’s service to the world in climate and oceans advocacy and UN Peacekeeping.

 

Comments are welcome and you can contact me in the strictest confidence at grubsheetcontact@gmail.com

 

(Feejee is the original name for Fiji - a derivative of the indigenous Viti and the Tongan Fisi - and was widely used until the late 19th century)

Copyright © 2022 Grubsheet - All Rights Reserved - For permission to republish any content or images from this blog please contact the author directly.